Warren Trophy donated by Bill Warren – a former treasurer of the league
| Year | Winners | Club |
| 2007 | C Andrews & D Berry | Sherwood |
| 2008 | R Button & I Armstrong | Carlton |
| 2009 | R Button & I Armstrong | Carlton |
| 2010 | W Marshall & J Slater | Ruddington |
| 2011 | W Marshall & J Slater | Ruddington |
| 2012 | R Button & P Moore | Carlton |
| 2013 | B Tring & R Smedley | Wilford |
| 2014 | M Giles & R Marson | Sherwood |
| 2015 | M Giles & R Marson | Sherwood |
| 2016 | M Bowling & R Chamberlain | West Bridgford |
| 2017 | K Broadley & S Birkin | Nuthall |
| 2018 | N Locke & V Harrop | Toton Lane |
| 2019 | S Dickens & P Dickens | Hucknall TP |
| 2020 | Not played due to Covid | |
| 2021 | S Dickens & P Dickens | Hucknall TP |
| 2022 | P Sidebottom & G Dickens | Nuthall |
| 2023 | P Sidebottom & G Dickens | Nuthall |
| 2024 | J Blanchard & G Lovatt | Clifton |
| 2025 | G Allen & H Lilley | Nuthall |